JazzboCR wrote:
While I wholeheartedly agree with Brother El Ciego's central thesis about power-grabbing by various social forces (how could I not?), I think he's conflating 2 very different social forces to make that point, We'll call one the Culture Crusaders who are now descendant as they were in the last period of economic agony the Great Depression, and the eco-warriors (alternatively the "nanny-staters") who are ascendant.
This opinion piece speaks about the moralists' virtual disappearance in times like these:
www.nytimes.com/2009/03/15/opinion/15rich.htmlAbout the "eco-warriors: I believe the esteemed Brother picked a bad target in using the full or partial ban on incandescent lightbulbs in favor of Compact Fluorescent Lights (CFLs). The US is among the last nations to ban then, behind the UK, European Union, Australia, to name a few. Now CFLs have some issues (not appropriate for limited-use areas like closets, and they contain mercury making disposal problematic) but overall the energy savings seem to warrant the ban. Here's 2 links talking about why:
www.howstuffworks.com/question236 http://lighterfootstep.com/2008/05/How- ... with-CFLs/ www.fightglobalwarming.com/page.cfm?tagID=608Of course you could say the hell with it and go to something even better than CFLs--that's LED lighting.
Yes. And the light is flicker-filled and inferior to incandescent light, particularly for reading tasks.
The reason I pulled this one out (incandescent v. CFL) is that it's another example of *someone* exerting control over my life.
Say I choose to be "green" by simply reducing the number of hours I use the incandescent lamp. I will save as much energy as someone who uses CFL constantly, and I'll be "greener," because incandescent bulbs are less polluting than the mercury-tainted CFLs. In other words, I'm an adult, capable of making good choices once I've learned the facts.
You'll be interested to know that I burn very few lights. It's not a blind thing; as I have light perception, light can be comforting. Rather I have made the choices I've made regarding energy consumption based upon economics.
So you see Jazzbo, it's not really a bad comparative example. It's one thing to educate the public and then allow the free market and individuals to make choices; it's quite another thing to attempt to micromanage the behavior of others.
"I wnat freedom. That's what I want, and that's what you should want! Liberal-conservative, Democrat/Republican... they're both the same. Two sides of the same corrupt coin. Two management teams vying for CEO of Slavery Incorporated."
- Alex Jones in the independent film "Waking Life."