Allow me to respond to your thoughtful post. (Time on my hands today)
Bilko wrote:
One last post by me on this subject. You say the Dow is up 8%. Retail price index was up 4%. The US dollar has dropped over 7%. To my eyes that rather wipes out an 8% gain in stock prices.
Friend: Just a couple corrections. The Economy grew by 4%, not the retail price index. Meaning our Gross Domestic Product grew by 4%.
The dollar dropping by 7% only has an effect the cost of imported goods or those traveling abroad. It really has no effect on domestic inflation.
The 4% growth in the economy is what is most significant. Most of this is due to growth in our export economy.
Bilko wrote:
You say: We go through a similar debacle and we barely miss a beat. Two points here. First, by NO means are we 'trough' the debacle. Housing inventories are at record levels, something like 10 months supply at current sales rate, assuming no more houses are added to the market.
You are not going to get an arguement out of me. Housing is phucked. If you are involved in Real Estate than you are in a recession.
The truth is th economy is steaming along inspite of these troubles. That is the big news.
Bilko wrote:
To say we have barely missed a beat is to ignore people losing their homes. Close to my old hometown of Sacramento is Stockton, where one of every 23 houses is in foreclosure. Stockton is an extreme example, but there are other areas where there are ghost town subdivisions...
I don't ignore, but it is sort of beside the point. The point is that the economy continues to grow dispite these problems.
When Japan went through this, everything fell apart as far as their economy is concerned. Meanwhile we are just plugging away. 4% growth in GDP in the face of these staggering financial problems is truely amazing.
Bilko wrote:
Using GDP to measure the economy's health is a common but delusional method. GDP counts consumer spending as if it were a product. It's not.
You and I can debate this point. Reality is that this is the means that virtually all economists use to gage the growth of an economy. I am not an expert, I am guessing neither are you. Since this is the measure that Expert Economist use, I will continue to consider it significant. Others can disagree.
Bilko wrote:
Other than the uppermost economic strata of the US population, most people's wealth has been found in their houses. With falling home prices and the home equity loans that have been taken out, this source of wealth is shrinking rapidly. Savings rates are NEGATIVE. There are people borrowing from their credit cards to make mortgage payments, foolish as this sounds.
There are some people that got themselves in really stupid situations. No question. Maxing out on Interest Only, ARM mortgages was pretty damn stupid. Many people have been hurt. No question.
No question that the Financial Markets are getting the crap kicked out of them right now. But look .......
It is a FACT, that the growth in our Export Economy has more than DOUBLED the amount of GDP that has fallen out of our economy because of this housing mess. Exports are going crazy right now, but that is not as obvious as the guy down the street that may loose his home.
It is also a fact that inspite of the housing mess our economy continues to create net new jobs and to grow our total earnings. This is HUGE!
As long as these TWO facts remain in play, we will get through the housing crisis. If either of those two things change, I will reevaluate.