Philo wrote:
Jazz Musician did it right. Here's a guy trying to do the same thing but is a little bit off (this is apparently for real).
Now Philo is missing the point. The question is not whether the cocky funny and approach is a good one OR whether guys are placing ads in CL along these lines. The question IS whether placing an ad this arrogant and self-absorbed actually WORKS AND GETS RESULTS.
Philo repeated the ad but conveniently left out the rest of the article that he got it from and so completely missed the entire point of that article. I'll start from where Philo left off but add some highlighting of my own:
San Francisco Chronicle wrote:
Ladies, ladies -- no mobbing me for his e-mail address!
Leaving alone for a moment the utter Cro-Magnon approach of this man, his very specific list of what he wants in a mate is pretty much a guarantee that it will take until the next ice age for him to get what he wants -- if ever.
I've heard other men hold forth this way as well: "If she twirls her hair or chews gum, it's all over." And women are just as bad. I have single friends who won't even consider a guy unless he clears at least most of her long list of qualifications. I've had friends end new relationships based on things like: His fingernails are too long, he likes John Tesh records, he goes/doesn't go to the gym every day, he thinks Bruce Willis movies are the best, he's a Republican.
And I'm right there with the worst of them. When I was set up on a blind date a few years ago, I immediately disqualified my friends' friend because he wore ironed jeans (a crisp crease in front) and loafers with tassels. (But I mean, come on!)
I do think as women get older, that perspective changes a bit. Women I know who are single and older than 50 or so eventually discover something interesting -- that just because a guy likes John Tesh doesn't mean he's not fun to hang out with. Perhaps we realize that if we want to date at all, it might be time to throw those lists out the window. (Men older than 50? I suspect their lists are every bit as long as they were 20 years earlier, but that's a subject for another column.)
Members of the younger generation, if one book is to be believed, are potentially doomed to live their lives single. Jillian Straus, the author of "Unhooked Generation: The Truth About Why We're Still Single" (Hyperion, $21.95), spent two years traveling the country and talking to 100 single men and women in six cities, including San Francisco, trying to come up with reasons that so many people in their 20s and 30s were vexed in their search for a soul mate. ....
[The article goes on to discuss this phenomenon as it applies to GenX-ers, which you can follow the link if you desire but I'll leave you with her closing comment]
.... Straus writes in her book about a guy she interviewed who said he was waiting to fall in love until he met his soul mate. And he would know her because she "took his breath away" when she walked into a room.
"He's still alone," Straus writes, "and waiting to be breathless."
The point is you could cockily insist on all the requirements in the world but that doesn't mean you're going to get them. Also, although the article was written by a woman largely from a woman's perspective, its a reality check that could apply just as easily towards us as it does to older women.
"Hey I'm an old, out-of-shape and embittered divorced man but at least I know what I want and they have to be young enough to be my daughter and willing to put up with my shit" Yeah, that should really get a huge positive response from all the young pretty women out there who will be so impressed with my honesty and arrogance. Not!