NYG wrote:
15 years in the same stable franchise and falied in 3 home afc championship games and one sb. Then Russ Grimm and Coach Wisenhunt had to beg him to let Big Ben throw the ball against the colts. HAD TO BEG

15 YEARS AND ONE RING WITH ALL THAT TALENT THE STEELERS HAD. Stupid, stuborn man and Shitty coach
Name me the current giant player that has had anything bad to say about Coach
All of them seem to blame themselves for the lost. they are all talking about how Coughlin leaves no stone unturned to prepare them to succeed

You sound like someone who will not be convienced and that is cool. If you do have PSL seats I maybe able to help you sell them. If you do not shut up
NYG
No offense, but it's a little ridiculous to suggest that because it took him a certain amount of time to win a SB with one team that it would hold true with a different one- there are thousands of different factors involved.
Still don't get why you are calling him stupid and saying he is a shitty coach, his W-L and playoff record blows Coughlin out of the water, also the very fact that he had 15 consecutive years there says something too. Just say if you don't like him, but calling him a stupid or bad coach is.....stupid and flies in the face of reality.
First off, no Giants are going to bad mouth Coughlin while he is still the head coach, out of respect for him, fear for themselves and a gag-rule that most teams employ. Secondly, I don't need any players to tell me he is not doing his job, I can see that perfectly clear from their performance and attitude during the game.
I sound like someone who is not going to be convinced of what?, that Coughlin is a great coach, even a good coach?. A good coach doesn't have what is going on the with Giants this year and the last 3 years happen. If they do then they are no longer a good coach. It's more and more apparent each year that the "magic" of '07 was largely do to Spagnola's influence in motivating and setting the enthusiasm tempo for the team.
I think this discussion has about played itself out and the decision is out of either one of our hands. Good luck to you and good luck to the Giants.