www.CostaRicaTicas.com https://forum.costaricaticas.com/ |
|
Lack of Calibration Raises Question About DUI https://forum.costaricaticas.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=41679 |
Page 1 of 1 |
Author: | Irish Drifter [ Wed Aug 22, 2012 5:08 pm ] |
Post subject: | Lack of Calibration Raises Question About DUI |
Quote: • Denounce calibration process abnormalities COURTS MAY CANCEL blood alcohol ANA V. AMENÃBAR C. An internal audit report of the Road Safety Council (Cosevi) reported to the Directorate General of Traffic (DGT) about the problems with the calibration of alcohosensores and therefore might eventually be challenged in a court. Asked about it, Silvia Bolaños, director of Cosevi confirmed to DAILY EXTRA who knew about the irregularities raised and said that since I was a traffic director César Quirós, issued instructions for correcting the errors, but unknown to date progress the process. Diego Herrera, director of traffic and it was named after the post Quirós was suspended, pending investigations into his relationship with the subject of the theft of weapons from the DGT; assured the top-selling newspaper that Costa Rica will not know how the process, however it is still being made roadside alcohol testing. ERROR IN PROCEDURE In the audit report are cautioned leaders of the DGT method for calibrating the measuring equipment using alcohol forwarding agents, are not written and are not authorized by the responsible officials, this was confirmed by the Mendez and Luis Araya official Eric Sequeira, who are currently responsible for the calibration of equipment, through the Operational Technical Unit. Even more delicate is that during the study was determined that neither the unit nor the two professionals are duly accredited by the respective entities and their actions not being duly authorized, are possibly questionable before a judicial authority. In this sense, the institution must credit those responsible for calibrating the equipment is the Costa Rican Accreditation Entity (ECA). Finally, it could be detected "when malfunctions occur alcohosensores, we proceed to perform simple repairs and / or light to achieve their operation, which can not be repaired fall into a state of neglect," the report said. Additionally cautions, unused parts or components to put into operation other equipment damaged, since they are not written off, which is an additional cost to the State. CRT was way ahead of the curve on expressing concern with the breathalysers used by the transitos. This thread is from January 2009. ![]() viewtopic.php?f=1&t=26871 |
Author: | DGD [ Wed Aug 22, 2012 6:50 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Lack of Calibration Raises Question About DUI |
ID: Not sure what machine CR is using. In US, so many problems with the Intoxilyzer 5000 and 8000 (most popular with USA local PD's) but are presumed reliable for evidentiary purposes. That means in the US, if you are trying to beat the blow, you need to hire an expert to show its scientific defects and unreliability, or how false teeth or belching or certain respiratory problems skew it, or the effect of the officer telling you to blow harder, or how other issues like police radios and other electronics in its vacinity affect it. Experts are expensive so most guys can't. Defendant's with the big bucks can beat the blow, but can they also beat the testimony of the officer who says you were in a ditch, passed out, couldn't walk, reaked, mumbled, resisted arrest, called the police a no good mf, pissed in his pants, etc, now alot of this often supported by dash mounted videos? No. It's the guys with the "just over" the limit blows with moderate field visuals and have the $$$ to hire an expert that can walk on a DUI. If it were me, and i knew i wasn't that messed up, I wouldn't blow. added penalties in most states for not blowing, but you are giving the prosecutors their dui case on a silver platter if you blow over. Don't do any of the field visual tests (walk the line, stand on one leg, touch your nose, say the alphabet--no penalty for refusing those, and even if you do fine they'll say you didn't). Be polite, say as little as possible, just get locked up and and deal with it in the morning. But, California S Ct finally made the maufacturer release its algorythms, which they fought for 10 years on proprietary issues. Don't know what machine CR locals are using, but I see where they were substituting parts in your quoted article. Last night, they grabbed a gorgeous 34 y.o. former Ms CR and she blew 3x over. She is/was sweet, see story and her foto. http://www.insidecostarica.com/dailynew ... 082205.htm PS: In the thread you cite there was a reference to police use of horizontal gaze nystagmus tests which is an eye exam administered by the officer focusing on the eye/pupil with a flashlight. Last time I noticed, only admissable in half the states. I saw a study that over half of 50 doctors who were tested on their technique and conclusions of the HGN failed, and these were in lab conditions. Now apply that to a roadside, in the dark, or whatever by a "trained" officer of the law. Pure trash. They will always say your pupil deviated, etc. |
Author: | Puravidatransport [ Wed Aug 22, 2012 11:46 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Lack of Calibration Raises Question About DUI |
I got stopped at a DUI checkpoint one night and know for a fact that machine was correct....showed I had 0.00 ![]() |
Page 1 of 1 | All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ] |
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group https://www.phpbb.com/ |