Tman wrote:
I guess I grew up old fashioned...there is never a reason to physically abuse a woman...or even respond in like kind.
I didn't mean to suggest there was. I'm not talking about decking the poor girl. But if she slaps you or tries to scratch you or something, it is appropriate to grab her wrists to restrain her physically or perhaps even some might give her a light slap back to give her a taste of her own medicine (not an option I would resort to, but hardly a major crime). If she goes all out on you, it might be appropriate to hold her down more forcefully. All these actions, including the ones you took could be construed technically as physical assault, if taken before the wrong judge or jury. I've seen it happen. Actually, it is assault even if you just lift your hand to threaten. Actual physical contact would be considered battery. Of course in these scenarios it is also appropriate to turn the other cheek or simply get away from her or if in your room ask her to leave or call hotel security if needed. So there are non-violent options that should be preferred before resorting to the physical ones mentioned above let alone the more extreme one that we suspect this gringo of having done.
Chicagoguy wrote:
There is never and good reason or excuse for raising a hand to a woman any time or any place..PERIOD
When you get right down to it some might say there is never any good reason or excuse to raise a hand to ANYONE any time or place. PERIOD There are always non-violent ways of dealing with any problems. I wasn't talking about good reasons or excuses for this guys behavior. I was talking about partially mitigating factors that while not making his actions excusable might make them more understandable.