DD,
I don't want to split hairs with you. I did read somewhere that some people skirt around the law in the way I discussed. I don't remember exactly where I saw it but if I find it I'll let you know. I will stand by a few of my other comments such as a similarity to the "perpetual tourism" example or the gringos working as employees under the table. This is CR where what is the letter of the law and what is practiced are often 2 different things.
I could turn your challenge around and ask you to tell me where it specifically says you do have to leave the money in the bank for the whole year. As with most loopholes, the proof is usually not so much in what it says but what it doesn't say. I've just rechecked at various websites including
http://www.costarica-embassy.org and
http://www.arcr.net and its not absolutely clear to me although I'll admit it doesn't look so simple.
One thing I said is definitely true, you don't have to post any funds in a
CR bank if you don't want to:
costarica-embassy wrote:
The applicant should provide an original document from the banking institution (in a foreign country or in Costa Rica) guaranteeing that they hold sufficient funds in a stable and permanent account to provide an income of US$ 1,000 per month for at least five (5) years
A US based annuity will definitely suffice for this.
I have seen reference to "irrevocability" but not at the CR embassy site and while permanent and stable suggests "irrevocability" there is nothing to stop someone from cashing in a CD before maturity through trading or closing out a bank account once the funds were demonstrated to be available. In fact, they require that you withdraw at least $1K/mo. They don't say anywhere you can't pull out more earlier.
As for depositing $60K in a CR bank or having a stable $1K/mo source of income being two alternative approaches rather than being mutal requirements, I'll quote from the arcr site:
arcr wrote:
[Rentista] Requires proof of US$1000 per month income for at least five years, guaranteed by a banking institution, OR a US$60,000 deposit in an approved Costa Rican bank.
Note: the OR in upper case caps is the way they wrote it not me.
Finally as for their checking up on you, I was wrong. It is every other year not annually. Again from the arcr:
arcr wrote:
Residency renewals are usually every second year. General conditions for renewal are 4 months residence in Costa Rica, the required amount of monthly income was changed into Costa Rican currency.
The last part of this quote is significant and just goes to show how ridiculous this whole discussion is.
ITS ALL MOOT. One is probably going to need at least $1K/mo to live on in CR anyway. Whether you keep the money in a low-interest CR bank account all year long, purchase an annuity from a US-based bank or somehow manage to withdraw the funds and invest them in some other hopefully higher yielding investment, you're still going to need to withdraw at least $1K/mo to live on from whereever you've stashed it and if you have to convert that money to colones before you pay your bills, whats the big deal.